Catie Wiley

Keeping the butter industry alive with my lovesickness

I’ve been covering myself in butter. Taking sticks of dairy and smearing them like sunscreen. Those hungry flies will come after me. Sooner or later. I’ve never learned how to say I love you. Even thinking of trying makes my blood curdle, aorta full of strawberry yogurt, and I doubt that Webmd has an article about that. So I keep my mouth shut. Every flutter in my stomach adds another ounce of butter. The brand doesn’t matter, but the spreadable kind works best on the face. When you say my name, I unfold another wrapper. When you send a text, I butterknife slice a tablespoon off and prepare for the inevitable. If you double text, or dare to triple, I spread a spoonful on my lips and pretend it’s a kiss. I know how weird this sounds. I know. My grocery bills have spiked. The cashier knows my name, and at this rate, I don’t know what to say to him. Hi Bill, I say, hiding my face. Bill says hi back and asks if I have a rewards card. He says it like he doesn’t already know the answer. I sigh with a no. Of course I don’t have one. That would be the reasonable thing to do and I don’t believe in being reasonable. I never have. I waddle out of the store like a duck full of shame, hands aching from those heavy bricks of dairy. I repeat I love you, I love you, I love you in my head, but my lips won’t form the sounds. My tongue said it’s taking a vacation day and who am I to argue? The more I think about it all, I really want to warn you: Don’t give me your heart, it will slip right out of my hands.

walking on eggshells

you gave me eggshell shoes for christmas,
no yolky sole to bear the brunt of the blisters,
but they shined so bright, so pretty,
I forgot to care about the comfort.

you gave me eggshell shoes
and I felt obligated to wear them,
encase my feet in their milky-toned crunch,
pretend the sound of their shatter
was my favorite song.

you gave me eggshell
shoes and I forgot how to run.
I couldn’t move more than an inch
in those prisons.
I got so tired,
I stopped trying.

you gave me eggshell shoes for Christmas
and you had this big smile
like you knew that I
could never leave.

exfoliate

Sand
scrapes my ankles
with every pull of the tide.
I like to think
that it’s scrubbing me.

I wear fear like a coat
of sunscreen;
I rub it into my skin
until it becomes me.

How do you peel off
a grease
this permanent?

Catie Wiley (she/they) is a lesbian writer from Maryland. She's a contributing editor for Story Magazine and a poetry reader for the winnow magazine. Their work appears in Wrongdoing Magazine, HELL IS REAL, and The B'K among others. Find her on twitter @catiewiley or at catiewiley.wordpress.com